Introduction
Modern political economy remains divided by an enduring theoretical impasse regarding the nature of market inequality and wage labor. On one side, neoclassical economics demonstrates with mathematical precision that price signals coordinate dispersed productive knowledge and that wage differentials reflect relative factor scarcity rather than intrinsic labor content (Hayek, 1945; Ohlin, 1933). Yet in treating the standard employment contract as the natural boundary condition of voluntary exchange, liberal and neoclassical traditions often overlook the structural asymmetry embedded within wage labor itself. On the other side, the Marxian tradition compellingly diagnoses worker alienation and surplus extraction within the employment relationship (Marx, 1867/1990). However, its reliance on the Labor Theory of Value and its prescription to abolish private markets led twentieth-century command economies to suppress local initiative and concrete economic coordination—an empirical failure later corrected in practice by DengXiaoping’s market-oriented reforms.
This study proposes Neo-Mencianism (Xin Meng Ruxue, 新孟儒学) not as a replacement for established economic science, nor as a sweeping metaphysical system, but as an interdisciplinary conceptual synthesis that bridges these divided traditions through classical Confucian political philosophy (Ling, 2001). Specifically, the framework integrates foundational insights—the settled “common sense”—from three distinct domains that are rarely placed into systematic dialogue:
- Neoclassical Microeconomics: It adopts standard supply-and-demand general equilibrium theory to explain legitimate wage differentials arising from talent and scarcity, while utilizing Joan Robinson’s (1933) monopsony framework (\(w^* – w’\)) to measure structural wage exploitation without relying on the Labor Theory of Value.
- Marxian and Reform-Era Chinese Political Economy: It retains Marx’s normative critique of workplace subordination and Mao Zedong’s late geopolitical refusal of both Western hyper-capitalism and Soviet central planning, while incorporating Deng Xiaoping’s practical recognition that concrete market incentives and decentralized knowledge are indispensable for economic vitality.
- Classical Mencian Ethics and Institutional Thought: It draws upon Mencius’s recognition that natural disparities among human capacities and goods are inherent to the order of things (wu zhi buqi, wu zhi qing ye, 物之不齐,物之情也; Mengzi 3A.4), alongside his institutional principle of pooling contributions and exchanging accomplishments (tonggong yishi, 通功易事; Mengzi 3B.4), to resolve structural exploitation within a market order.
The central argument of this paper is that each of these three traditions illuminates a vital truth while remaining incomplete in isolation. Neoclassical economics explains how markets allocate scarce resources efficiently, yet lacks a normative critique of the employment contract. Marxian political economy exposes the subordination inherent in selling one’s labor-power, yet lacks a market-compatible contractual alternative. Classical Mencianism supplies the missing institutional bridge. By distinguishing natural differentiation (ziran fenhua, 自然分化)—disparities generated by effort, talent, and scarcity—from secondary differentiation (erci fenhua, 二次分化)—extraction arising from the employment contract—Neo-Mencianism shows how modern economies can preserve market efficiency and private capital while replacing the exchange of labor-power (yili, 易力) with cooperative partnerships grounded in the exchange of completed accomplishments (yishi, 易事).
The Full Text manuscript by Shan Ling titled “NeoMencianism:A Complete Philosophical Analysis” is available as preprint at Research Square https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-10450718/v1
Key References
- Hayek, F. A. (1945). The use of knowledge in society. American Economic Review, 35(4), 519–530.
- Ling, S. (2001, August 7). Dangdai Zhongguo daolu de Ruxue jieshi: Ziran fenhua yu erci fenhua [当代中国道路的儒学解释:自然分化与二次分化 A Confucian interpretation of the contemporary Chinese path: Natural differentiation and secondary differentiation]. Huaxia Shibao 华夏时报[China Times].
- Marx, K. (1990). Capital: A critique of political economy (Vol. 1; B. Fowkes, Trans.). Penguin Classics. (Original work published 1867)
- Mencius. (1970). Mencius (D. C. Lau, Trans.). Penguin Classics.
- Ohlin, B. (1933). Interregional and international trade. Harvard University Press.参考 云儿:物以稀为贵的经济学解释(自然分化)https://wp.me/po2t3-1Sa
- Robinson, J. (1933). The economics of imperfect competition. Macmillan.参考yqy:西方实证经济学对剥削概念的数学解释(二次分化)https://wp.me/po2t3-1FN
发表评论